What’s in a name? – On the subject of re-titling films

What comes to mind when you hear the title Edge of Tomorrow? Immediately I think of an action film but the ‘tomorrow’ part certainly speaks of something just a tad futuristic, perhaps even science-fiction. That’s all very well but my views have been nothing if not a little aggressively informed by the film that until recently, bore this title. The more important question is whether I would see a film based solely on how the title sounded, without prior knowledge. I know this seems a bit like a stupid question, given that the marketing for any film encompasses advertisements in all shapes and sizes as well as trailers all designed to whet my appetite for an upcoming cinema release, but clearly a lot of stock is put in the name of a film. It’s quite often the first thing you hear about a film.

Naming films is an interesting task, and depending on the film itself, you’ll want to get across quite different ideas. It has to be done with some skill and flair though because the average audience member can spot a sloppy title a mile away – I’m looking at you sequels, you can’t just slap a ‘2’ on the end and be done with it! Unless you’re Toy Story…or Spider-man…or Evil Dead…or Shrek. Hmmm. Regardless, the title of a film is important and gets you thinking. It can entice you, or it can worry you or put you off entirely. For example…

In recent news, the third Hobbit film was given a new title. Gone was ‘There and Back Again’ and in its place came ‘The Battle of the Five Armies’. Peter Jackson has stated that the nature of the film he has put together did not fit with the original title but this does conjure up some worrying thoughts. Are we going to see a 3+ hour film with nothing but build-up and then a colossal hour-long battle scene? If so, has Jackson completely lost the plot by focusing on a battle that Tolkien hardly dwells on in his book? Is this just silly Rings-fanboy fretting? I sincerely hope so. Still not a great title though. Moving on to another franchise, no one asked for another Die Hard film after Die Hard 4.0/Live Free or Die Hard (another bizarre change for different regions) but we got one anyway, in the form of A Good Day To Die Hard, a film with a title so ridiculous that even Bruce Willis didn’t know what it meant. By adding a fifth (unwanted) entry into the franchise and therefore continuing to ram repetitious clichéd action down the throats of viewers, they should have at least called it…Old Habits Die Hard. I might have wanted to watch that.

Live Die Repeat DVD

As I mentioned at the start, the film Edge of Tomorrow is the reason for this little ramble, since it no longer goes by this name. At least not entirely. Recent reports and checks on Amazon reveal that it can now be found under the title of Live Die Repeat: Edge of Tomorrow. What is surprising about this is its timing, occurring slap-bang between the theatrical release and the home video release dates. Films often make their way through scripting and production under various guises, sometimes used to throw nosey reporters off the scent and sometimes because there isn’t a better title yet, but rarely does a film change its identity after it appears in cinemas.

So why the name change you ask?

Well, to get things started lets reiterate a fact that I’m sure everyone knows – the film industry is run on money. Money money money. It makes the cinematic world go round. Production companies and distributors need films to make money and it appears that Edge of Tomorrow did not make enough on the big screen. What was the cause of this? The cast list? I hardly think so. Tom Cruise and Emily Blunt are two of the best actors working in the business today and I for one would line-up to see any movie that the latter was in. Cruise ain’t too bad neither. Reviews were generally quite positive and the marketing was fine, so it can’t be those. It did have some heavyweight competition at the box office in the form of X-Men: Days of Future Past and Transformers: Age of Extinction, so it could be that, but apparently not. The blame has been attributed to the title, and an attempt has been made to fix this before the DVD and Blu-ray hits shelves, but is the new title better?

On the face of it, I have to agree that Edge of Tomorrow isn’t the catchiest or most memorable title I have come across. It’s quite generic for a summer blockbuster, and while it might cause you to ask the question I opened with, it’s too vague to stick. Live Die Repeat is much snappier and really drives home the main plot point without spoiling too much; you get the picture because its simplicity practically bludgeons you. It’s not necessarily better on its own, but attaching the old title makes it far worse. If it were up to me I would have tried to go with the title of the original novel, All You Need Is Kill, which has an eyebrow-raising strangeness to it that gets my mind cogs a-whirring.

Finally, we move to our last question – will the renaming bring success in the home media market? To be blunt (pun intended), probably not. The new title is far from a massive improvement over the old and the whole process seems to have been a messy one. Case in point, to try to retain the original cinema audience and hopefully pull in a large home viewing audience, the chosen title is an amalgamation – Live Die Repeat: Edge of Tomorrow – which is clumsy at best. The likely scenario is that Edge of Tomorrow will live or die on the opinions of those who have already seen it. As someone who has I hope more people discover it and enjoy it because it is a good film. Good enough to heartily recommend. Even if it were called Bang Bang Alien Invasion: I Love Mech Suits.

Click here for my review of Edge of Tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s